Cyclic Defrost

An Australian magazine focusing on interesting music

Mark Jenkins – This Island Earth (Ricochet Dream)

Mark Jenkins - This Island Earth

Mark Jenkins was initially inspired to make music by hearing Mike Oldfield and Tangerine Dream in the 1970s. In 1985 he progressed to founding his own label – Amp Records – and has since played many solo concerts at venues around the world, and released almost a dozen albums.

Jenkins claims that his latest disc This Island Earth is like Cluster and Tangerine Dream. Well, having listened to a lot of krautrock in my time, I can tell you that this album sounds nothing like Cluster, and only superficially resembles some of Tangerine Dream’s 1970s/80s work. Mark Jenkins has copied some of Edgar Froese’s trademark sounds and styles, but seems to have completely missed the adventurous, surreal, psychedelic spirit at the heart of TD’s greatest work.

This Island Earth contains three suites of music: ‘New Jersey Shore’; ‘This Island Earth’; and ‘The Graveyard of Dreams’. Most potentially interesting to an erstwhile (oh, alright then – not so erstwhile) sci-fi nerd is the central suite ‘This Island Earth’. This is themed around the classic 1955 film of the same name starring Jeff Morrow and Rex Reason. I had high hopes for this – but the opening track ‘Flight Through the Green Ray’ sounds like really bad 80s funk-lite – complete with horns cheesier than a ripe gorgonzola. Next track ‘Exeter’s Challenge…’ loses the lame beats (one is grateful for small mercies) and goes in a more ambient direction. ‘At War with Zagon…’ has some cool dialogue excerpts from the movie, but the synth sounds, tunes and arrangements are just so uninspired that it’s hard to keep listening. ‘Crash Landing Earth’ closes the piece with cliched-sounding strings and more forgettable melodies.

I have nothing against good old-fashioned synth music, but really, don’t waste your time on copies – go for the originals – Tangerine Dream and Jean-Michel Jarre.

Ewan Burke

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

*

  • http://www.markjenkins.net Mark Jenkins

    Hi Ewan,

    Thanks for your attempt to review “This Island Earth”. If you can’t spot the similarities between the style of the opening suite and the 1970′s music of Moebius and Roedelius (aka Cluster), or between the closing suite and Tangerine Dream’s “Ricochet”, then perhaps your listening has been more restricted than would be expected from someone setting out to be a published music reviewer.

    But pointing up stylistic similarities in the promotion of a CD is merely an attempt to give signposts to the potential listener. There’s no question of having “copied” Edgar Froese’s trademark sounds and styles (or if I can do so in the 2000′s using a laptop rather than a studio full of 1970′s keyboards then I must be pretty clever after all), but to criticise an album for having “missed the adventurous, surreal, psychedelic spirit at the heart of TD’s greatest work” is at best mean-spirited. It would be quite astonishing had it managed to do so.

    And to require listeners to “go for the originals”, Tangerine Dream and Jarre, when it’s well known that neither artist is turning out music these days at a level which is even listenable, is simply crass.

    Bye-bye!

    Mark Jenkins
    http://www.markjenkins.net

Slow Flow Rec Click Clack Project Running On Air Get a web advert! Audego Get a web advert!
Subscribe to posts via email

Cyclic Defrost is Australia’s only specialist electronic music magazine. We cover independent electronic music, avant-rock, experimental sound art and leftfield hip hop. Read more

Postal Address:
P.O.Box A2073
Sydney South
NSW, 1235
Australia

Email: info[at]cyclicdefrost.com

australia council Wordpress

RSS feed icon RSS

The views contained herein are not necessarily the views of the publisher nor the staff of Cyclic Defrost. Copyright remains with the authors and/or Cyclic Defrost.